Prayer: To Whom Shall We Go? Luke 11:1-13

PanentheismJesus’ teaching on prayer in the gospel text Luke 11:1-13 begs the question: “To Whom Shall We Go?” Liberated from perceptions that reduce images of the MYSTERY we call God to those of a cosmic superhero, who abides up or out there ready to manipulate events here in the world at the request of those who pray, the activity of prayer takes on a whole new meaning and shape. Our images of who, where and what the MYSTERY is will direct our prayers in ways that impact our expectations of prayer. Who do we pray to and what we expect of the ONE who hears our prayers will shape how and why we pray.

Before we can even begin to understand what so much of the Christian tradition means when it talks about praying to God, we need to take a step back and look at what we mean when we say the word “god.” Throughout the Jewish and Christian traditions you can trace two very distinct ways of understanding and talking about the MYSTERY that we call God.

The first and most familiar way of understanding God is as a supernatural being. The CREATOR of ALL is described as a sort of person, a supernatural person. The term supernatural describes it all, super means beyond the natural. DIVINITY is understood as a being beyond the capabilities of most beings. DIVINITY is personified; given the characteristics of a person; only it is as if this image of God has the powers of a super-hero; someone far greater than we can even imagine. This way of thinking about DIVINE MYSTERY comes naturally to us. As children many of us had imaginary friends, and so it’s easy to move from our imaginary friends that share the same characteristics as us (except for the fact that they are invisible) to thinking about a God as a kind of super-imaginary friend. DIVINE MYSTERY is often understood as a person who exists out there or more often up there; separate and apart from us, who from time to time intervenes or speaks to us.  But this is not the only way to think about DIVINITY.

Within the Christian tradition there has always been another way of thinking and talking about DIVINE MYSTERY. This way of thinking about DIVINITY reminds us that the CREATOR of ALL is not a person who exists out there, but rather as  it says in the book of Acts, God is the ONE in whom we live and move and have our being. According to this way of understanding DIVINITY, MYSTERY is the ONE in whom we live. DIVINITY is not out there or up there, but right here all around us. DIVINE MYSTERY is the encompassing SPIRITt in whom everything that is, IS.  (the Ancient Hebrews used the verb “to be” or IS to describe this MYSTERY in Exodus when the DIVINE ONE takes on the name YHWH – I AM, or I WILL BE) This other way of understanding God has a fancy theological name: panentheism  – “pan” means everything, “en” means in, and “theo” means god = everything is in God.

Panentheism is a way of understanding MYSTERY at a non-material level, or layer, or dimension of reality that pervades the universe. DIVINITY is described as being all around us and within us;  the universe and everything in it is permeated with the presence of the DIVINE MYSTERY that we call God. This less familiar way of understanding DIVINITY may be less familiar to us than supernatural theism, but Panentheism is just as ancient and just as Christian.

Panentheism, is nothing new.  It is deeply rooted in the Christian tradition. It is found throughout the scriptures. Unfortunately, maybe because it is easier, the church for the most part has opted to use supernatural theism in worship.  So, liturgies and prayers are created in ways that relate to God as a super-person. But when we think of God as a super-person it constrains our understanding of DIVINITY.

The DIVINE MYSTERY that IS,  is so much more than a super-person. Don’t get me wrong, there is absolutely nothing wrong with relating to MYSTERY as a super-person. The problem begins when that is the only way we think of God. Eventually the super-person “himself” becomes an idol and we are left practicing idolatry.

The DIVINE MYSTERY that IS is more than a super-person. DIVINITY is the force or SPIRIT that permeates the universe and everything that is in the universe. The DIVINE ONE is not the universe, nor is God anything that is in the universe. The universe is in God. We are not God, we are in God.

When we think about the MYSTERY as the ONE who permeates the universe we then have to look differently at everything that is in God including our very selves and especially our neighbours. Panentheism may be new to some, so let me suggest some ways of understanding the DIVINE ONE in ways that move us beyond the super-hero.

When we say I, “I believe in God,”  I am not saying that I believe that God is some other-worldly super hero. I see the ONE as the UNCONDITIONAL, the ULTIMATE, the DIVINE, who IS present in ALL, and is ALL—all of life, all persons, all creatures, all the universe, and I believe that there is more than we can perceive or comprehend, a dimension beyond the apparent world of time and space.

The commandment to “love God with all your heart, with all your mind, and with all your strength is a commandment to love creation, to love experience, and to love the radical MYSTERY that is at creations’ centre  with all my heart, with all my mind and with all my strength. The knowledge that DIVINITY is present in all our fellow beings explains why the commandment to love God is violated when we fail to love our neighbour.

When we look at DIVINE MYSTERY from the perspective of panentheism we begin to see ourselves and our neighbours not only as in God, but also as potential expressions of God.  Back when I was in seminary, I remember being blown away by this particular way of relating to the ONE who IS. It changed the way I think about myself as a human being and as a Christian and it changed the way I pray.

Panentheism moves us beyond the image of God that we have created and opens us to the reality of the force that lies at the very heart of creation; a force that lives and breathes in, with, through, and beyond us. When we move beyond seeing DIVINITY as a super-person, to understanding DIVINITY as that which permeates all that IS, we are compelled to open ourselves to a power beyond our ability to name. In the presence of such a DIETY our prayers can seem like hubris, ridiculously childlike, or even useless and so we are all too often reduced to a silence born out of frustration rather than intention. But however, we arrive at the silence, it is out of the silence that the DIVINE ONE comes to us and we hear the Bat Cole, the Daughter of a Sound, “the still small voice of God” who dwells in, with, through, and beyond us.

1 thought on “Prayer: To Whom Shall We Go? Luke 11:1-13

  1. This is a Wonderfully, Informative essay Pastor Dawn Hutchings has provided for All her readers on “Panentheism”-a necessary word for doing theology and understanding spirituality today. Panentheism, the concept that the Mystery we refer to as God is in Everything in Creation and in Every Human Being and every creature and in every rock, tree, and ocean etc. including you and me is so important for doing the work of theology. I remember when I was introduced to “Panentheism” in 1962 (my first year in seminary) when studying the sermons and theology of Paul Tillich, one of the most significant theologians of the 20th century. As a right brain person I was thrilled and knew I was “at home” in Christian theology as presented by Tillich and others. Panentheism is so Gospel centered and Incarnationally focused. After reading Pastor Dawn’s wonderful words, I encourage everyone to listen to Bp. Spong and Fr. Richard Rohr as provided by Pr. Dawn. You will be glad you did!
    Pastor Jon R. Fogleman

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s